2014 Champagne Philipponnat, Clos des Goisses, Extra Brut Jancis Robinson MW 17++/20 Antonio Galloni 94-96/100 James Suckling 95/100 Ready - at best
Champagne Henri Giraud, MV16, Grand Cru, Aÿ, Brut Jancis Robinson MW 17.5/20 Alison Napjus 94/100 Antonio Galloni 97/100 Ready - at best
2009 Champagne Philipponnat, Clos des Goisses, Extra Brut Jancis Robinson MW 17/20 93/100 Antonio Galloni 96+/100 Ready - mature